Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Luxury Hotels in Montauk, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| Hilton Mystic |
8.5 / 10 (615 Reviews) |
From 119$ | |
| Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End By Ihg |
9.2 / 10 (140 Reviews) |
From 174$ | |
| Saybrook Point Resort & Marina |
9.3 / 10 (282 Reviews) |
From 294$ | |
| Marina Bay Cottages |
8.7 / 10 (204 Reviews) |
From 161$ | |
| The Hotel Maria |
9.3 / 10 (86 Reviews) |
From 225$ |
Great luxury hotels in Montauk
View all photos
Hilton Mystic
From 119$
Located nearly 5 minutes' walk from the 4-star Hilton Mystic Hotel, guests can quickly reach Foxwoods Marine Theater. This Mystic hotel features 182 rooms and comforts such as a convenience shop and a restaurant.
Offering an indoor pool Hilton Mystic Hotel provides guests with a sunbathing terrace and a picnic area.
View all photos
Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End By Ihg
From 174$
Situated 2.6 km from Peconic River, the 4-star Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End By Ihg Riverhead offers car for rent. Featuring 12 rooms with views of the garden, this comfortable hotel is 10 minutes' drive from Safari Adventure.
This Riverhead hotel features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool as well as a shared lounge, a golf course, and spa services. There is a fitness suite with a wide range of sports.
View all photos
Saybrook Point Resort & Marina
From 294$
The 4-star smoke-free Saybrook Point Resort & Marina Old Saybrook is a mere 300 metres from Connecticut River and features facials, a sundeck, and massage therapy. Located within a 4-km distance of Cornfield Point, this Old Saybrook hotel offers a solarium, a steam room, a Jacuzzi, and a sauna.
A health club and an indoor pool are available at the Saybrook Point Old Saybrook. Sports lovers will enjoy boating and mini golf.
Spa luxury hotels in Montauk
View all photos
Marina Bay Cottages
From 161$
Featuring a patio and a picnic area, the 4-star Marina Bay Cottages Waterford hotel is nestled about 7 km from Hygienic Art gallery. The hotel provides guests with Wi-Fi in public areas.
Guests can access a game room to add excitement to their stay. This property offers sport activities, such as ping-pong and billiard.
View all photos
The Hotel Maria
From 225$
Situated nearly 10 minutes' walk from Misquamicut State Beach, the elegant The Hotel Maria Westerly offers 31 rooms. While staying 4.5 km from Napatree Point Nature Preserve, guests can benefit from a sunbathing terrace, a shared lounge, and a golf course.
Hotels in Montauk
| Best Price Hotel 🤑 | Hilton Mystic |
| Best mid-range Hotel 🌴 | Hotel Indigo Long Island - East End By Ihg |
| Best reviews Hotel ❤️ | Saybrook Point Resort & Marina |
View all photos
The Shoals Suites & Slips
From 199$
The comfortable The Shoals Suites & Slips Southold hotel lies approximately 6 km from a natural paradise like Catapano Dairy Farm, and features a restaurant. Boasting access to Greenport, around 10 minutes' drive away, this 4-star smoke-free hotel includes a sunbathing terrace and a shared lounge providing guests with comfortable rooms.
View all photos
The Sea Breeze Inn
From 198$
Offering a sundeck and a picnic area, as well as the views of the sea, the 4-star The Sea Breeze Inn Middletown is located around a 25-minute walk from The Old Stone Mill. This cosy hotel features both Wi-Fi throughout the property and private car parking on site.
View all photos
Grand Lake Hotel
From 80$
10 minutes' drive from Zagray's Farm, the 5-star Grand Lake Hotel Lebanon offers an American restaurant on site. Casa Martinaj restaurant and the outdoor bar are available at the hotel boasting a prime location in Lebanon.
With a fitness area that offers fitness classes, the Grand caters to guests' physical well-being.
View all photos
The Historic General Stanton Inn
From 197$
Featuring air-conditioned rooms and an American restaurant, the elegant The Historic General Stanton Inn Charlestown is 3.2 km from Ninigret Park. This 5-star hotel boasts views of the garden and offers Wi-Fi in the rooms.
Guests will appreciate live performances organised at this Charlestown hotel.
View all photos
Shepherd'S Run
From 377$
Featuring an outdoor swimming pool, the comfortable 4-star Shepherd'S Run South Kingstown hotel offers a photocopy machine and a work desk, as well as Wi-Fi in public areas. Located around a 10-minute drive from Point Judith Fisherman's Memorial, the smoke-free hotel offers a treatment room and a hot tub.
The accommodation goes the extra mile to provide guests with fitness classes to help them stay fit. There is a fitness centre with a wide range of sports.
View all photos
Sleep Inn & Suites Niantic North
From 140$
Offering air-conditioned rooms and Wi-Fi in public areas, Sleep Inn & Suites Niantic North is 2.1 km from Flanders Baptist Church and 15 minutes' walk from Christ Lutheran Church. Featuring a prime location, the hotel includes an indoor pool and an exercise room, plus guests can visit Niantic Bay Boardwalk, which is 4.2 km away.
View all photos
American Beech Hotel - Greenport
From 321$
The 4-star smoke-free American Beech Hotel - Greenport offers access to Dering Harbor Marina, which is located nearly a 25-minute walk away. Featuring Wi-Fi in public areas, this Greenport hotel also has amenities such as a restaurant and a gift shop.
View all photos
Comfort Suites Near Casinos
From 99$
Located about 10 minutes by car from Dodd Stadium, which is highly appreciated by sports lovers, the family-friendly Comfort Suites Near Casinos Norwich hotel includes 259 rooms. The 4-star hotel also includes a car park.
The Comfort Suites Norwich also includes a sauna and spa therapy. Onsite sports-related facilities include a heated pool, an exercise room along with fitness classes.
View all photos
Mystic Marriott Hotel And Spa
From 151$
The comfortable Mystic Marriott Hotel And Spa Groton is situated near the business district of Groton, approximately 20 minutes' walk from Kiely Park. This 4-star smoke-free hotel serves American dishes and offers a steam room, a sauna, and a foot bath, boasting a setting near a train station.
This hotel also features a swimming pool as well as facials, a sunbathing terrace, and a shared lounge. Keeping fit at the Mystic is convenient thanks to a fitness centre that offers fitness classes.
View all photos
Rodeway Inn & Suites Branford - Guilford
From 80$
Located 3.6 km from Stony Creek Village, the 4-star newly renovated Rodeway Inn & Suites Branford - Guilford is in close proximity to Saint Therese Catholic Church. A garden adorned with barbecue grills enhances the ambiance of the comfortable hotel.
Guests can work out in a fitness centre during their stay.
View all photos
Journey East Hampton
From 315$
The comfortable 4-star Journey East Hampton Hotel, located approximately a 10-minute drive from Balsam Farm Stand, offers a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and Wi-Fi in public areas. The smoke-free hotel is in the East Hampton North district of East Hampton, within a 2-km distance of such natural sights as the undeveloped Egypt Beach.
View all photos
The Maidstone Hotel
From 300$
Situated about a 5-minute stroll from Home Sweet Home Museum, the comfortable 4-star The Maidstone Hotel East Hampton offers air-conditioned rooms, Wi-Fi, and parking. This East Hampton inn offers an à la carte restaurant and features convenient location with a such place of power and worship as Saint Luke Episcopal Church only 0.6 km away.
View all photos
Faraway Sag Harbor
From 219$
The 4-star Faraway Sag Harbor Hotel, located just 5 minutes' walk from Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum and a mere 1.2 km from Sag Harbor Marine Park, features an outdoor swimming pool for guests to take a dip in. Boasting a fitness room and a private garden, the hotel is within 4 km of Foster Memorial Town Beach.
Guests can make different arrangements at the property, including canyoning and cycling or rent bicycle to explore Sag Harbor. You can play tennis at this hotel or go fishing.